Study guides · Jainism

Anekāntavāda: The Jain Philosophy of Many-Sidedness

What anekāntavāda, syādvāda and the doctrine of standpoints actually say, who developed them, and why they matter for philosophy.

Jain philosophy is best known for its principle of non-violence, but its most original contribution to Indian thought may be its theory of knowledge. The doctrine of anekāntavāda, which can be translated "the doctrine of many-sidedness", holds that reality has many aspects and that no single statement captures it completely. Popular accounts reduce this to a parable and a moral about tolerance. The classical texts say much more, and they present a careful logic.

The basic idea

For the Jains, every real thing has infinitely many characteristics. A jar is a substance that persists, but its shape and colour change, and it is also a collection of clay particles, an object of use and, from another view, a product of a potter's action. Any one description picks out one aspect. To say a thing simply "is" or "is not", permanent or impermanent, would be one-sided (ekānta), and the Jains argue that such one-sidedness is the root of philosophical error. The term anekānta negates it. The doctrine is therefore a claim about the nature of reality as well as about the limits of speech.

Standpoints and the seven-fold predication

Two technical tools give the idea its shape. The first is the theory of nayas, or standpoints. A naya is a partial viewpoint that states one aspect truthfully, for example by treating a thing in terms of its enduring substance, or by treating it in terms of its momentary modes. Statements made from a standpoint are true as far as they go and false only if they claim to be the whole truth. The second tool is syādvāda, the doctrine of "maybe" or, more accurately, "in some respect". The word syāt prefixed to a statement signals that it is true from a given standpoint. The classical texts set out seven forms of predication, called saptabhaṅgī. In them, a statement can be affirmed from one standpoint, denied from another, both affirmed and denied in succession, and inexpressible when both are considered together, and the remaining combinations follow. The scheme is an attempt to show how apparently conflicting claims can be both true when properly qualified.

The elephant and the blind men

The parable most often told in modern books is that of the blind men and the elephant, each of whom touches one part and takes it for the whole. It is commonly connected with Jain thought and has been used to illustrate anekānta. The story actually appears first in Buddhist literature, in the Udāna, where it is told to criticise the quarrels of rival teachers, and it was later adopted in several Indian traditions. It is a helpful illustration, but it is not a presentation of the Jain theory, for the Jain claim is not only that each person sees a part but that the elephant itself has many aspects, all of them real.

Who developed the doctrine

The roots lie in the canonical texts, where Mahāvīra answers questions with qualified replies. The systematic form was created by later philosophers. Siddhasena Divākara, probably in the fifth century, wrote the Sanmatitarka, an early work on the theory of standpoints. Samantabhadra, a Digambara teacher of perhaps the sixth century, composed the Āptamīmāṃsā, which uses syādvāda to criticise rival philosophies. Akalaṅka in the eighth century and Haribhadra, also in the eighth, and later Hemacandra and Mallisena, whose Syādvādamañjarī of 1292 is a commentary defending the theory against Buddhist and Brahmanical critics, developed it further. Their works show that anekānta was not only a moral ideal but a position in the arguments that Indian philosophers conducted with each other.

Criticism and reception

Rival schools did not always accept the Jain position. Śaṅkara, in his commentary on the Brahmasūtra, argued that a thing cannot be both existent and non-existent, so that the doctrine collapses into confusion. Buddhist logicians raised similar points. Jain thinkers replied that the objection overlooks the difference of standpoints. Modern philosophers have found the doctrine interesting in connection with pluralism, with many-valued logic and with the problem of perspective. Interpreters differ about whether it commits Jainism to relativism, and most historians say it does not, since the Jains held that there is a true account that omniscience grasps in full.

The doctrine in later authors

The principles of anekāntavāda were developed over many centuries by Jain philosophers who wrote in Sanskrit and Prakrit. Siddhasena Divākara and Samantabhadra, writing in about the fifth and sixth centuries, set out the logic of standpoints. Haribhadra, in the eighth century, wrote studies of rival schools in which he tried to understand them fairly. Hemacandra and Mallisena, in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, gave classic summaries, and the Syādvādamañjarī of Mallisena is a commentary that defends the doctrine against critics. Reading these authors shows that the doctrine was part of a living debate and not a fixed slogan.

Comparisons and modern use

Scholars often compare the Jain approach with the fourfold analysis used by Buddhist philosophers, and with the later Madhyamaka argument that things lack inherent nature. The comparison is useful, but the aims differ: Jain thinkers hold that reality really is complex and that each standpoint grasps part of it. In modern times, many writers have invoked the doctrine in discussions of tolerance and interfaith dialogue, and Mohandas Gandhi was influenced by Jain ideas through his early contact with Jain teachers in Gujarat. Critics point out that the philosophical doctrine is not the same as a general rule of tolerance, and that the two should not be confused when reading classical texts.

Reading further

A first-time reader should start with a general account of Jain philosophy and then read a translation of a classical text such as the Tattvārthasūtra, which provides the doctrinal background. Our Jain pages list scholarly translations, the university centres teaching Jain studies and the journals where research appears.

Key points to remember

Anekāntavāda teaches that reality is complex and can be described truthfully from different standpoints, none of which alone gives the whole. Its logic of qualified statements, syādvāda, and its analysis of standpoints, nayavāda, were refined by Jain philosophers over many centuries and used to answer rival schools. Remember the story of the blind men and the elephant as an illustration and not as a proof. Distinguish the philosophical doctrine from general tolerance, and read the classical sources and good modern studies to see how it worked.

Further reading

  • Bimal Krishna Matilal, The Central Philosophy of Jainism (Anekāntavāda) (L. D. Institute of Indology, 1981).
  • Jeffery D. Long, Jainism: An Introduction (I. B. Tauris, 2009).
  • Paul Dundas, The Jains, 2nd edition (Routledge, 2002).
  • Padmanabh S. Jaini, The Jaina Path of Purification (University of California Press, 1979).

Related on this site

This guide is an introduction written by a research scholar of Buddhist and ancient history from standard scholarly literature. Dates and figures for the ancient world are often debated, and where scholars disagree we have said so. If you find an error, please write to contact@theancientdharma.com.

↑