Study guides · Ancient Civilizations
The Indus Valley Civilization: What We Know and What Remains Unread
The cities, crafts and trade of the Harappan world, the unread script, and the debates over its decline.
The Indus Valley Civilization, also called the Harappan, was one of the three great early urban cultures, alongside Mesopotamia and Egypt. Its cities were rediscovered only in the 1920s, and a great deal about it is still open to question, above all because its writing has not been deciphered.
Discovery
Harappa, in Punjab, had long been known to British officials, but its importance was not understood until excavations in the early 1920s. Work at Mohenjo-daro in Sindh, led by R. D. Banerji, and at Harappa, led by Daya Ram Sahni, led John Marshall to announce a new civilization in 1924. Seals like those found at these sites were identified with seals from Mesopotamia, which helped to date the culture. Later work found hundreds of sites, extending across what is now Pakistan and northwest India, with Dholavira, Lothal and Rakhigarhi among the major ones.
Cities and crafts
The Mature Harappan period is usually dated to about 2600 to 1900 BCE. Its cities were laid out on planned grids, with brick-lined drains, wells and in some cases large buildings such as the "Great Bath" at Mohenjo-daro, whose purpose is debated. Bricks were made in standard proportions, and weights followed a consistent system. Craftspeople made beads of carnelian and other stones, pottery, copper and bronze tools, and carved seals showing animals and signs. No palaces or royal tombs have been firmly identified, and this is one reason scholars argue over how these cities were governed.
Trade and connections
Harappan objects, including seals and beads, have been found in Mesopotamia and the Gulf. Mesopotamian texts mention a land called Meluhha, which most scholars link with the Indus region. The Harappans traded in stone, metals, shell and timber. Evidence of farming includes wheat, barley, cotton and cattle.
The script
Harappan writing appears mainly on stamp seals and tablets. It has around four hundred signs, and the inscriptions are very short, most of them only a handful of signs long. No long text and no bilingual inscription, which could provide a key, has been found. Many proposals for decipherment have been made, but none has been generally accepted, and some scholars even question whether the signs record a language at all. For this reason, claims to have "deciphered" the Indus script should be treated with caution.
Decline
From about 1900 BCE the large cities declined, and settlement shifted in many areas toward smaller villages and toward the east and south. Older explanations of a violent invasion are no longer favoured. Current research looks at changes in climate and monsoon patterns, shifts in river courses and the effects on trade, and many scholars now see a gradual, regionally varied change in place of one sudden collapse.
Seals, figures and interpretation
Many of the best-known Harappan objects carry labels given by modern scholars that should be read with caution. The small stamp seals, usually of carved steatite, show animals such as the so-called unicorn, bulls and elephants, together with signs. A seal showing a seated figure with horns, once called "proto-Śiva" or "Paśupati" by early excavators, has been interpreted in many ways, and there is no firm evidence of what it meant. The same is true of the bronze "dancing girl" and the stone "priest-king" from Mohenjo-daro, names that reflect the assumptions of the 1920s and 1930s more than anything known about the figures themselves.
Recent research
Work continues at many sites. At Dholavira in Gujarat, excavators found an elaborate system of water reservoirs, and the site was inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in 2021. At Rakhigarhi in Haryana, a study of ancient DNA from a skeleton, published in 2019, has been discussed in debates about the relation of the Harappans to later populations, though a single individual cannot settle such a question. There is also a long debate about the role of the dried-up Ghaggar-Hakra river system, which some researchers connect with the Sarasvatī of Vedic texts. These topics attract strong opinions, so the safest practice is to read excavation reports and peer-reviewed studies, and to treat popular claims about a "decipherment" or a dramatic discovery with care.
Earlier roots
The Harappan cities did not appear from nowhere. At Mehrgarh in Balochistan, excavations led by Jean-François Jarrige have shown farming settlements from around 7000 BCE, with the cultivation of wheat and barley and the herding of cattle, sheep and goats. Over the following millennia, villages became larger and developed regional styles of pottery, until the Mature Harappan period brought a more uniform culture across a wide area. Understanding this earlier sequence helps to show that urban life grew out of long local development.
Everyday life and exchange
Evidence from the cities points to specialised crafts, careful drainage and trade over long distances. Harappan merchants obtained lapis lazuli from Afghanistan, copper from the Aravalli hills and Oman, and shell from the coast. The site of Lothal in Gujarat contains a large brick basin that some excavators identified as a dockyard, though others suggest it served as a water tank. Such debates are typical of the field, in which interpretation changes as new evidence appears.
Debates to follow
- How the cities were governed in the absence of obvious palaces.
- What language or languages the Harappans spoke.
- How much continuity there is between Harappan and later South Asian culture.
- The role of climate in the decline.
Some of these questions have been affected by modern politics, so look for authors who base claims on excavation reports and published evidence. Our Ancient Civilizations pages list libraries, museums and journals, and the guide on writing systems explains why decipherment depends on the kind of evidence available.
Key points to remember
The Indus civilization is known from archaeology and not from readable texts. Its cities, standard weights and bricks, seals, crafts and trade link show a highly organised society, but its language, government and religion remain uncertain, and the script is undeciphered. Treat popular labels such as priest-king or proto-Śiva as modern names. Follow excavation reports, remember that the decline was probably gradual and regional, and be careful with claims that connect the civilization with later periods without clear evidence.
Further reading
- Jonathan Mark Kenoyer, Ancient Cities of the Indus Valley Civilization (Oxford University Press, Karachi, 1998).
- Gregory L. Possehl, The Indus Civilization: A Contemporary Perspective (AltaMira Press, 2002).
- Rita P. Wright, The Ancient Indus: Urbanism, Economy, and Society (Cambridge University Press, 2010).
- Andrew Robinson, The Indus: Lost Civilizations (Reaktion Books, 2015).
Related on this site
- Ancient Civilizations canon on this site
- Study guide: writing systems and decipherment
- Study guide: dating the ancient world
- Ancient Civilizations libraries
- More study guides
This guide is an introduction written by a research scholar of Buddhist and ancient history from standard scholarly literature. Dates and figures for the ancient world are often debated, and where scholars disagree we have said so. If you find an error, please write to contact@theancientdharma.com.