Study guides · Confucianism & Taoism

Mencius and Xunzi: The Great Debate on Human Nature

Why two Confucian thinkers disagreed about whether human nature is good or bad, and what the argument shows about early Chinese ethics.

Confucius left no systematic account of human nature. His followers had to decide what he would have said, and two of the most important answered in opposite ways. Mencius held that human nature is good. Xunzi, writing about half a century later, declared that it is bad. Their disagreement is one of the oldest and most productive arguments in Chinese philosophy, and understanding it clarifies what each meant by the key words.

Two thinkers in the Warring States

Both men lived in the Warring States period (475 to 221 BCE), a time of constant war among rival states and of intense intellectual debate, often called the age of the "hundred schools". Mencius (Mengzi, traditionally 372 to 289 BCE) travelled from court to court offering advice to rulers, usually without success. His teachings were recorded by disciples in the book that bears his name. Xunzi (traditionally around 310 to 235 BCE) was a more systematic writer and held office in the state of Chu. The book called Xunzi contains essays, many probably from his own hand, on subjects including ritual, music, language and learning.

Mencius: the sprouts of goodness

Mencius argued that human beings have an innate tendency to goodness. His famous example concerns a person who suddenly sees a child about to fall into a well. Anyone would feel alarm and compassion, he says, not out of a wish to win praise or to please the parents but spontaneously. This feeling is the "sprout" of humaneness (ren). He identifies four such sprouts: compassion, shame, deference and a sense of right and wrong, which can grow into the virtues of humaneness, righteousness, ritual propriety and wisdom. Evil results when circumstances and neglect stunt these sprouts, as a mountain is stripped of trees by constant cutting and grazing. The task of education and self-cultivation is to nourish what is already there. Mencius also argues that rulers must secure the people's livelihood, since people cannot develop morally in the midst of hunger.

Xunzi: the crooked wood

Xunzi's chapter "Human Nature Is Bad" attacks this view directly. By nature, he says, people are born with desires for profit and for pleasure, and left to follow these they quarrel and plunder. Goodness is artifice (wei), the result of deliberate effort. He compares it to crooked wood, which must be steamed and bent to become straight, or to blunt metal, which must be whetted to become sharp. The sage kings created ritual and moral norms to reshape unruly human nature, and each person becomes good by learning and accepting them. Xunzi is not saying that people are hopeless. He insists that anyone can become a sage through accumulated effort, a view in which education, teachers and ritual play a larger role than in Mencius.

Why they really disagreed

The two men may be using the word xing, "nature", in different ways. For Mencius, it refers to what is distinctively human and which develops under proper conditions, as a tree's nature is to grow tall. For Xunzi, it refers to what is given at birth before any training, such as appetites. Read that way, the disagreement is less about whether people can become good, which both affirm, than about where the work is done. Mencius looks inward and stresses the cultivation of moral feeling. Xunzi looks outward and stresses the authority of rites and teachers. These different emphases influenced later Confucians. Neo-Confucians of the Song dynasty, particularly Zhu Xi, championed Mencius and placed his book among the Four Books, and Xunzi was long regarded with suspicion as a heterodox figure, partly because two of his students, Han Fei and Li Si, became architects of the harsh Legalist policies of the Qin state.

Other voices in the debate

The debate also involved other thinkers. In the Mencius, a philosopher named Gaozi argues that human nature is like willow wood, which can be carved into cups or bowls, or like swirling water that can be directed east or west, and Mencius replies that water naturally flows downward. The Mohists, followers of Mozi, argued for impartial concern for all and a morality based on benefit, and Daoists such as Zhuangzi questioned the whole project of moral cultivation. Seen against these alternatives, Mencius and Xunzi share more than they differ.

Later influence

Mencius became the more influential figure in later Confucian tradition. In the Song dynasty, Zhu Xi included the Mencius among the Four Books, and it became part of the standard curriculum. Xunzi's influence was more indirect but still large. His emphasis on ritual and education shaped Han thought, and two of his students, Han Fei and Li Si, became leading figures in the Legalist movement that supported the unification of China under the Qin. In his essay on Heaven, Xunzi also argued that natural events have no moral meaning, a position that stands out in the early Chinese context.

Modern study

Recent scholarship has revived interest in both thinkers. Philosophers compare Mencius to virtue ethicists who stress the development of a good character, and Xunzi to thinkers who stress habit and institutions. Bryan Van Norden's translation of the Mengzi with traditional commentaries, and Eric Hutton's translation of the Xunzi, are good starting points for readers who want to follow this debate in English.

Where to read

Irene Bloom's translation of the Mencius and Eric Hutton's translation of the Xunzi are reliable starting points, and Bryan Van Norden's Mengzi includes selections from traditional commentary. Our Confucianism and Taoism pages list the classics, commentaries and journals, and the Chinese Text Project gives access to the original texts.

Key points to remember

Mencius and Xunzi shared the aim of making people good through education and ritual, but they disagreed about the starting point. Mencius held that humans have moral sprouts that must be nurtured, while Xunzi held that natural desires lead to conflict unless shaped by ritual and learning. Both influenced Chinese thought for two thousand years, Mencius more directly through the Four Books and Xunzi through the thinkers of the Han and the Legalists. Read them side by side to see how a basic question can produce two rich philosophies.

Further reading

  • Irene Bloom (trans.), Mencius (Columbia University Press, 2009).
  • Eric L. Hutton (trans.), Xunzi: The Complete Text (Princeton University Press, 2014).
  • Bryan W. Van Norden (trans.), Mengzi: With Selections from Traditional Commentaries (Hackett, 2008).
  • Philip J. Ivanhoe, Confucian Moral Self Cultivation, 2nd edition (Hackett, 2000).

Related on this site

This guide is an introduction written by a research scholar of Buddhist and ancient history from standard scholarly literature. Dates and figures for the ancient world are often debated, and where scholars disagree we have said so. If you find an error, please write to contact@theancientdharma.com.

↑