Study guides · Ancient Greece & Rome

Herodotus and Thucydides: Two Ways of Writing History

How the first two great Greek historians worked, what they wanted to explain, and how to read them as sources.

Our word "history" comes from the Greek historia, meaning inquiry. The two earliest historians whose works survive in full, Herodotus and Thucydides, did not write in the same way, and a reader who understands the difference will read each more usefully.

Herodotus: the inquirer

Herodotus came from Halicarnassus on the coast of Asia Minor and wrote in the middle and later decades of the fifth century BCE. His Histories set out to record the great deeds of Greeks and non-Greeks and to explain why they came into conflict. The central subject is the Persian Wars, which ended with the Greek victories of 480 and 479 BCE, but the work ranges widely, with long sections on Egypt, Scythia, Lydia and Persia. He gathered stories from many places, often says that he is reporting what he was told, and sometimes gives two versions without choosing. This openness is why later writers called him a storyteller, and also why he is a rich source for peoples whose own records are few.

Thucydides: the analyst

Thucydides, an Athenian, wrote about the Peloponnesian War between Athens and Sparta, which lasted from 431 to 404 BCE, and which he lived through. He served as a general and was exiled after a failure at Amphipolis. His work breaks off in the middle of the twenty-first year of the war. He claimed to write for lasting use and rejected the pleasing story. In his opening chapters he explains his method, including the way he composed speeches, which gave the sense of what was needed in each situation as closely as he could to what was actually said (1.22). He looked for causes in the growth of Athenian power and the fear it created in Sparta, and he gave close attention to politics and human behaviour.

Differences in method

  • Scope: Herodotus looks across the known world, while Thucydides keeps to one war.
  • Time: Herodotus describes events of the previous generation and earlier, while Thucydides writes of events he saw himself.
  • Explanation: Herodotus allows divine signs and personal motives, while Thucydides stresses power, interest and circumstance.
  • Style: Herodotus is discursive, and Thucydides is dense and compressed.

It would be wrong to treat one as scientific and the other as naive. Herodotus was careful about his sources in many places, and Thucydides shaped his account through selection and the speeches he composed.

Using them as sources

For Persian history, Herodotus must be checked against the inscriptions and tablets described in our Persia guide, which sometimes confirm him and sometimes do not. For the war between Athens and Sparta, Thucydides can be compared with later writers such as Xenophon, who continued the narrative, and with inscriptions, including Athenian decrees. Ask in each case where the author's information could have come from.

Famous passages

Two passages show the contrast. In his account of the funeral oration, Thucydides gives Pericles a speech (2.35 to 46) praising Athens as a school for Greece, which many readers take as a statement of Athenian ideals. A little later (5.84 to 116) he writes the Melian Dialogue, a conversation between Athenian envoys and the people of the island of Melos, in which the Athenians argue that the strong do what they can and the weak accept what they must. Thucydides himself says he composed such speeches, so they are best read as his analysis of Athenian attitudes and not as a transcript.

Herodotus offers a different pleasure. His story of the Lydian king Croesus and the wise Athenian Solon, or his account of the Egyptian priests, shows his interest in customs and in how people explain their own past. Cicero called him "the father of history", and he was also criticised in antiquity, notably by Plutarch, who wrote a work accusing him of malice.

What came afterwards

Later writers took up both models. Xenophon continued Thucydides' narrative from 411 BCE in his Hellenica. In the second century BCE, Polybius wrote a history of Rome's rise that stresses causes and the lessons of experience in the manner of Thucydides, and Roman historians such as Livy and Tacitus adapted Greek methods to their own history. Reading Herodotus and Thucydides first makes it easier to see what these later authors inherited.

A reading plan

For Herodotus, begin with the first book, which introduces Croesus of Lydia and the rise of Cyrus, and then read the story of the Persian invasion in books seven to nine. The long Egyptian section in book two is a good example of his interest in customs, and can be read on its own. Herodotus tells his tale by linking stories, often returning to a theme in a ring-like pattern, and a patient reader will see how digressions prepare the main narrative. Archaeology has confirmed some of his reports, such as the Scythian burial mounds on the Black Sea steppe, and corrected others.

For Thucydides, read the first book to understand the causes of the war and his method, then the Funeral Oration, the account of the plague at Athens (2.47 to 54), the Melian Dialogue and the Sicilian expedition in books six and seven, which he narrates with great force. Keep a map and a list of the main commanders beside you, because the narrative moves quickly between places.

Choosing a translation

Annotated editions with maps, such as the Landmark editions of both authors, are well suited to a first reading. Penguin and Oxford offer reliable alternatives. The Perseus Digital Library hosts Greek texts with free translations. Our Greece and Rome canon page lists these along with the Loeb editions.

Key points to remember

Herodotus and Thucydides together define two enduring styles of history: the wide inquiry into peoples and customs, and the focused analysis of one war and its causes. Neither is simply objective, and both composed their narratives with care. Use Herodotus for the Persian Wars and for the wider world of the fifth century, and use Thucydides for the Athenian and Spartan conflict. Compare each with inscriptions and later writers, ask where the information came from, and read an annotated translation with maps.

Further reading

  • John Marincola, Greek Historians (Oxford University Press, Greece & Rome New Surveys, 2001).
  • Simon Hornblower, Thucydides (Duckworth, 1987).
  • Robert B. Strassler (ed.), The Landmark Herodotus (Pantheon, 2007).
  • Robert B. Strassler (ed.), The Landmark Thucydides (Free Press, 1996).

Related on this site

This guide is an introduction written by a research scholar of Buddhist and ancient history from standard scholarly literature. Dates and figures for the ancient world are often debated, and where scholars disagree we have said so. If you find an error, please write to contact@theancientdharma.com.

↑