Study guides · Buddhism

When Did the Buddha Live? The Long and Short Chronologies

Why the traditional date for the Buddha's death was questioned, how the reign of Aśoka anchors the debate, and what most scholars now think.

Few facts in Buddhist history look as simple as the date of the Buddha, and few are as disputed. Buddhist communities in Sri Lanka and Southeast Asia count years from the Buddha's death, traditionally placed in 544 or 543 BCE. Most modern historians think this is too early by a century or more. Understanding why is a good lesson in how ancient chronology works.

The problem of evidence

No inscription or document from the Buddha's own lifetime survives. The early texts record events but do not give years in any calendar. Dates therefore have to be worked out indirectly, by counting forward from the Buddha's death to a king whose date can be fixed from outside sources, or by dating the cultural world that the texts describe.

The anchor: Aśoka

The emperor Aśoka of the Maurya dynasty is the best anchor. His Rock Edict 13 names five Hellenistic rulers who were his contemporaries, among them Antiochus II of Syria, Ptolemy II of Egypt and Antigonus Gonatas of Macedonia. Because the reigns of these kings are known from Greek sources, historians date Aśoka's consecration to roughly 268 BCE. Aśoka's inscriptions also show his support for the Buddhist community, and one at Lumbini records that he visited the place where the Buddha was born.

The long chronology

The Pāli chronicles of Sri Lanka, the Dīpavaṃsa and Mahāvaṃsa, say that Aśoka was consecrated 218 years after the Buddha's death. Counting back from about 268 BCE gives a death date near 486 BCE. This is sometimes called the corrected long chronology. The traditional date of 544 or 543 BCE results from a longer count of reigns in the Sri Lankan record. Some scholars also prefer the Indian and Chinese traditions that put the interval to Aśoka at about a hundred years, which produces a very different result.

The short chronology

In 1988 a major symposium led by Heinz Bechert in Göttingen examined the question, and its papers were published as The Dating of the Historical Buddha. Many contributors argued for a later date, with the Buddha's death around 400 BCE, give or take a few decades. Their reasons included the evidence of the lists of teachers in the Buddhist and Jain traditions, which suggested fewer generations than the long chronology required, and the archaeological record of urban life in the Ganges valley, where the cities mentioned in the early texts seem to have developed in the fifth century BCE rather than earlier. Richard Gombrich proposed a death date of about 404 BCE. Other scholars still defend a date nearer to 480 BCE, so the question is not settled.

What the debate depends on

  • Interval to Aśoka: whether the chronicles' figure of 218 years is reliable or reflects later calculation.
  • Lists of teachers: the length of the succession from the Buddha to Aśoka's time.
  • Archaeology: when towns, brick buildings, coins and writing became common in the middle Ganges.
  • Parallel figures: the dates of the Jain leader Mahāvīra and of kings such as Bimbisāra and Ajātasattu, which are also uncertain.

Archaeology and the early cities

Archaeology provides indirect evidence. In the middle Ganges valley, excavations at sites such as Kauśāmbī, Rājghāṭ near Varanasi and Śrāvastī show that planned towns with fortifications and a fine grey pottery known as Northern Black Polished Ware appear in the middle of the first millennium BCE. If the cities mentioned in the early Buddhist texts did not yet exist, or were small, in the sixth century BCE, this favours a later date for the Buddha. The evidence is not simple, because regions differ and dating methods have limits. Excavations at Lumbini directed by Robin Coningham, reported in 2013, claimed to find a timber structure beneath the Māyādevī temple dated to about the sixth century BCE, but this finding has been questioned and does not by itself settle the date of the Buddha.

How to cite the date responsibly

The safest way to write about the Buddha's date is to give a range, state which chronology you are using and cite one of the major discussions. A phrase such as "the Buddha, who lived in the fifth century BCE or perhaps a little later" is accurate to the present state of knowledge. When using Southeast Asian Buddhist sources, remember that the year count of the Buddhist Era begins from the traditional date, so conversions to the common era should be checked against the system in use.

Other Asian traditions

The question has been answered very differently outside the Pāli tradition. Chinese and Tibetan sources give many different dates, and some Chinese texts place the Buddha's life in the first millennium BCE much earlier than any modern scholar would accept, often in the tenth or eleventh century BCE, partly for reasons of religious and political prestige. Tibetan traditions also record several systems. These variations show that, for most of history, communities used the date that suited their own sources and needs.

The 2,500th anniversary

In 1956, the Theravāda Buddhist world celebrated the 2,500th anniversary of the Buddha's death, known as the Buddha Jayanti, on the basis of the traditional date of 544 or 543 BCE. Governments in India, Sri Lanka, Burma and Thailand took part in the observance, and the occasion gave a new impetus to Buddhist scholarship and publication, including editions of the Pāli Canon. The celebration shows how a traditional chronology can become part of modern religious and national life, even when historians prefer another date.

Why the date matters

A shift of a century changes the setting in which the teaching arose. In the earlier view the Buddha lived before the great growth of Ganges cities and long before the Mauryan empire. In the later view he lived in a time of rapid urban and political change that may help to explain his ideas. Whichever date is preferred, careful writers give a range, such as "fifth century BCE", and explain why. Our guides on the Pāli Canon and the Buddhist councils show how the same texts help to build a picture of that world.

Further reading

  • Heinz Bechert (ed.), The Dating of the Historical Buddha / Die Datierung des historischen Buddha, 3 parts (Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1991–1997).
  • Richard Gombrich, "Dating the Buddha: A Red Herring Revealed," in Bechert (ed.), The Dating of the Historical Buddha, part 2 (1992).
  • Rupert Gethin, The Foundations of Buddhism (Oxford University Press, 1998).
  • Upinder Singh, A History of Ancient and Early Medieval India (Pearson, 2008).

Related on this site

This guide is an introduction written by a research scholar of Buddhist and ancient history from standard scholarly literature. Dates and figures for the ancient world are often debated, and where scholars disagree we have said so. If you find an error, please write to contact@theancientdharma.com.

↑