Before the Buddha Image: Aniconism, Gandhāra and Mathura
Why early Buddhist art shows the Buddha as a tree, a throne or a footprint, how the first images appeared, and how art historians argue about it.
One of the best-known puzzles in the history of Asian art concerns a missing figure. The earliest surviving Buddhist monuments in India, from the last centuries BCE, tell the story of the Buddha's life in stone, yet they never show him as a human being. Instead, a tree, an empty throne, a wheel, a pair of footprints or a stūpa stands where we expect the person. Only in the first or second century of the common era does the Buddha begin to appear as a human figure. How and why the image arose has been argued about for more than a century, and the debate shows how art historians weigh evidence.
What the early monuments show
The great stūpas of Bharhut and Sanchi, built and decorated between roughly the second century BCE and the first century CE, are covered with narrative reliefs. They show scenes from the Buddha's life and from the Jātaka stories of his earlier births, set among trees, gateways and crowds of worshippers. In scenes of his enlightenment, a tree under a throne marks his presence, and in scenes of the first sermon, a wheel stands for the Dharma he set in motion. Worshippers approach these symbols with offerings, and in some scenes they honour a place where the Buddha has been. This is called aniconism, from the Greek for "without an image".
Two cities, two claims
The first human images of the Buddha appear in two regions at about the same time. In Gandhāra, in what is now northern Pakistan and eastern Afghanistan, sculptors working in schist and stucco combined Indian subject matter with a vocabulary borrowed from the Hellenistic and Roman world: wavy hair, draped robes with deep folds and a naturalistic body. In Mathura, in north-central India, sculptors working in red sandstone produced images with a broad-shouldered, powerful presence in an Indian style. Coins issued by the Kushan emperor Kanishka, probably in the second century CE, show a figure identified in Greek letters as the Buddha, which is a valuable dated reference point, although the precise date of the reign is itself debated.
In the early twentieth century, the French scholar Alfred Foucher argued that the Buddha image was a Greek invention, created in Gandhāra under the influence of classical art, and that Indians had previously refrained from showing him for reasons of reverence. Ananda Coomaraswamy answered in 1927 that the image was a natural development within Indian tradition, rooted in earlier images of popular deities known as yakṣas, and that Mathura had produced the first images independently. Each side captured something. Modern scholars generally see the two centres as drawing on each other and on shared Indian ideas of the divine and the ideal body, and they avoid the earlier either-or framing.
Was it really a rule?
A second, more radical, challenge came from the art historian Susan Huntington. In a widely discussed 1990 article she argued that the theory of a deliberate ban on images does not fit the evidence. No early text forbids images of the Buddha, and the symbols may not have been "substitutes" for a figure at all. They could have had their own meaning, representing relics, places of pilgrimage or aspects of the teaching. If that is so, then the "absence" is something later scholars have projected. Other specialists, among them Vidya Dehejia, responded that the pattern is too consistent to be accidental and proposed that the symbols were deliberately used as emblems of presence. The question remains open, and it illustrates a general lesson: a missing thing is easy to see, and hard to explain.
Looking at a Buddha image
Once the image exists, a standard visual language develops. The Buddha is shown with a protuberance on the head (uṣṇīṣa), elongated earlobes, a mark between the eyebrows (ūrṇā), and a monk's robe. Hand gestures, called mudrās, signal particular moments: the earth-touching gesture recalls the enlightenment, and the wheel-turning gesture the first sermon. These conventions travelled with Buddhism to Central Asia, China, Korea, Japan and Southeast Asia, where they were joined to local styles, so that a Buddha from Sri Lanka, Dunhuang or Kamakura Japan can be recognised and also dated and placed by details of dress, face and material.
When you study an object in a museum, ask a few simple questions. What is it made of, and where was that material available? Is there an inscription naming a donor, a date or a lineage? Does a record state where it was found? This last point is not a minor one. Many Gandhāran sculptures entered the art market through illegal excavation, which destroys the context that gives them meaning. Responsible study therefore pays attention to provenance, the documented history of ownership, and prefers objects with a secure findspot and collection history.
Coins and the earliest dated images
Gold coins issued by the Kuṣāṇa king Kaniṣka, probably in the second century CE, show a figure labelled in Greek script as "Boddo", which is among the earliest securely identified images of the Buddha on a datable object. These coins are important because they place the image in the context of a ruler's court and a cosmopolitan trading empire, and they show that the Buddha figure had a place in royal imagery as well as in monastic art.
Spread across Asia
From Gandhāra and Mathurā, the Buddha image travelled along the trade routes to Central Asia, China, Korea and Japan, and by sea to Southeast Asia. Each region adapted the figure to its own tastes, changing the dress, the face and the posture. Learning to recognise the standard gestures, or mudrās, and the signs of the Buddha, such as the cranial protuberance and the elongated earlobes, allows a viewer to read an image from any of these regions.
Where to see and study
Many museums now publish their collections online and allow free use of images of public-domain works. The Metropolitan Museum of Art's open-access programme and the Smithsonian's National Museum of Asian Art are good places to start, as are the online collections of the British Museum, the Musée Guimet and the Rijksmuseum. Our Art History pages list collections, libraries and journals, and the Community page lists fellowships and conferences.
Further reading
- Susan L. Huntington, "Early Buddhist Art and the Theory of Aniconism," Art Journal 49, no. 4 (1990).
- Vidya Dehejia, "Aniconism and the Multivalence of Emblems," Ars Orientalis 21 (1991).
- Susan L. Huntington with John C. Huntington, The Art of Ancient India: Buddhist, Hindu, Jain (Weatherhill, 1985).
- Ananda K. Coomaraswamy, "The Origin of the Buddha Image," The Art Bulletin 9, no. 4 (1927).
- Benjamin Rowland, The Art and Architecture of India: Buddhist, Hindu, Jain, 3rd edition (Penguin, 1970).
Related on this site
This guide is an introduction written by a research scholar of Buddhist and ancient history from standard scholarly literature. Dates and figures for the ancient world are often debated, and where scholars disagree we have said so. If you find an error, please write to contact@theancientdharma.com.